Sardine Fasting: What is it and What Are the Pros and Cons?

By: Mike Geary – Certified Nutrition Specialist and Author of the best sellers The Diabetes Fix and The Truth About Testosterone

If you follow a lot of the social media health influencers, there’s been a popular type of fasting a lot of people have been talking about this year, and they call it “sardine fasting”.

I’ve been getting a lot of questions about sardine fasting from our readers (feel free to reply to any newsletters we send if you want to request topics for us to cover, or for questions)…

So I’m going to break down the benefits and the downsides of sardine fasting for you today.  Because there are risks with extreme diets like this.

Basically sardine fasting involves doing a multi day fast (3-5 days), but instead of not eating any food at all (which is very stressful to the body and very hard to do), a sardine fast allows you to at least eat maybe 500-600 calories a day from sardines only.

As a nutritionist, I see many problems with this overall, but I will point out a few short term benefits as well.

The Possible Benefits:

For some people, a 3-5 day “sardine fast” allows them to drop some weight fairly fast (I’ve heard of 5-7 lbs being common in 3-5 days), while not losing as much muscle as a pure water fast since the sardines contain significant protein and healthy fats and micronutrients.

Another benefit for people who eat a lot of unhealthy junk food is that it restricts all food except sardines for these days and might help break food addiction to junk foods.

Sardines are also high in omega-3 fats, selenium, vitamin D, B12, and a few other important nutrients which could help certain people that are lacking in these nutrients (it would really help a vegan or vegetarian since they do typically lack these nutrients).

Now for the risks and downsides…

The Possible Harms:

Since this is only a 3-5 day semi-fast, the risks are minimized as long as you get back on a balanced diet ASAP after those 3-5 days.

This is because this is an extremely restrictive way of eating, and the lack of healthy carbohydrates (and lack of calories in general) will increase stress hormones significantly, as well as lower your thyroid levels (not good).

It also lacks any fiber or prebiotics (for gut health), and also lacks a diversity of vitamins and minerals that aren’t found in sardines, such as vitamin C and other important vitamins.

A very low calorie and low-carb “semi-fast” like this can also worsen your sleep during these 3-5 days.  This is because without any carbohydrates, your cortisol spikes and can make you feel overly awake and “wired” and make it hard to sleep.

Another downside is that people who have tried sardine fasting have reported that they start to smell like fish after a few days, which I can’t imagine is good for your romantic life. 🙂

Lastly, any of these kinds of “cleanses” or fasts don’t really teach balanced long term eating for success… instead they rely on an extreme fad to try to dig out of a hole of normally bad eating.

So I’m not saying that this is the worst idea, and I have seen some people get good short term results as long as they get back on a balanced diet after the few days on the sardine fast.

But it’s not something that’s appealing to me personally, and I’d rather just eat a balanced diet of healthy grass-fed meats, organic fruits, potatoes and sweet potatoes, grass-fed yogurt, etc.

By the way, speaking of fish…

The #1 Fish You Should NEVER Buy At The Grocery Store

Eating fish is good for your heart, right?

WRONG.

Dr. Sam Walters – top heart expert & NASA nutrition consultant – is exposing one of the biggest lies in heart health today.

If you’re worried about your cholesterol, blood pressure, or triglycerides…

Or if you have heart problems…

There’s 1 type of fish you should NEVER buy at the grocery store.

Click here to see what it is

About Alan Pendlebury